Skip to main content

The Trial Lawyer's Journal

TLJ Small Logo
Close
Group 39053677
Share Your Story with Trial Lawyer’s Journal
Trial Lawyer’s Journal is built on the voices of trial lawyers like you. Share your journey, insights, and experiences through articles, interviews, and our podcast, Celebrating Justice.
Stay Updated
Sign up for our newsletter to get the latest from TLJ.



    A hurricane seen from space, its white spiral of cloud wound tight around the eye over a dark sea

    Hurricane Hustle: Inside the Rise and Fall of MMA

    Part 1 Trial Lawyer’s Journal No. 03
    HurricaneHustle
    Inside the Rise and Fall of MMA
    Scroll ↓or use arrows ↑↓
    Editor’s note

    Editor’s note: This article first appeared in Trial Lawyer’s Journal No. 03, which was submitted to print in September 2025. It is republished here as it ran in print, reporting as of that date, with minor copy corrections. Numbered notes mark corrections, clarifications and developments since publication; a summary of corrections follows the article. A follow-up, Part 2, will follow.

    The rain had stopped months ago, but the house still smelled like a damp towel left too long in a closed bathroom.

    In the quiet days after devastating Hurricane Laura, a woman — let’s call her Maria — kept her couch on cinder blocks “just in case,” the floor bowed in the shape of the storm that had come once and never fully left. Her roof was peeled back by Laura’s winds, the rain coming through the ceiling in sheets. She’d taken photos before the drywall sagged, saved the claim number her insurer gave her, and called every week for an update that never came.

    Then, six months later, a stranger’s voice rang through her phone.

    He said he was with a law firm. He knew her name, her address, the day the hurricane hit. He asked a few questions, promised they could help her get the payout she deserved. The next day, a contingency contract landed in her inbox. She signed before dinner.

    Maria isn’t real — she’s a fictional character created for this article. In that way, she’s a bit like the man on the phone, who wasn’t really a lawyer either.

    What our fictional Maria didn’t know — and what thousands of real clients didn’t know — was that her information had been gathered, sold, and processed by a marketing company hundreds of miles away; that her case would be one of thousands in a system running faster than any small team of trial lawyers could follow; that she might never meet her attorney; that the first human being who really spoke to her wasn’t a lawyer at all; and that the firm she’d hired — McClenny, Moseley & Associates, the Texas shop that branded itself “MMA” — had already pledged the value of clients like her to outside lenders.

    Her case wasn’t just a case; it was collateral.

    Three bolts of lightning strike the sea beneath a dark shelf of storm cloud
    01

    From Storm Surge to Client Surge

    MMA’s journey from obscurity to infamy is a parable of modern lawyering gone awry, involving high-volume lead generation, outside investors hungry for returns, and lax oversight — until the courts stepped in. The firm’s two named partners, Zachary Moseley and James Lee McClenny, started MMA in Houston, focusing initially on routine insurance and personal injury cases. By 2020, they had a modest practice (and little footprint outside Texas). Then Hurricane Laura slammed southwest Louisiana in August 2020, followed by Hurricane Delta, and a year later Hurricane Ida devastated New Orleans and its environs. These storms collectively generated tens of thousands of insurance claims — and, inevitably, disputes and lawsuits when insurers underpaid or denied them. Local Louisiana firms were signing up many storm victims, but Moseley and McClenny saw an opportunity to represent “thousands” of claimants and made a strategic push into Louisiana, despite having only a few Louisiana-licensed lawyers.

    What MMA lacked in local presence, it sought to make up for with sheer marketing firepower.

    In mid-2021, MMA contracted with a marketing firm called Velawcity (pronounced like “velocity”) to turbocharge client intake.1 Velawcity’s business was finding claimants for lawyers, and it offered MMA a turnkey solution: a “Storm Damage Call Center” that would use targeted ads and a call center to deliver signed contingency fee contracts en masse.

    For MMA, which needed to scale up fast, it was an offer too good to pass up. Internal emails show MMA handed Velawcity its client contract template and even let Velawcity suggest tweaks to it. Velawcity personnel promised MMA a “really good return rate on contracts being signed” — and they had ideas on maximizing it.2 For instance, one Velawcity employee noted the fee contract’s footer had been removed and told MMA they thought they would “need to have the footer added back in for fee splits.” In other words, Velawcity was involved in arranging how any legal fees might later be shared — a red-flag indication that this was no ordinary ad service, but a partner in the enterprise.3

    On August 29, 2021, just as Category 4 Hurricane Ida was knocking out power in New Orleans, MMA was busily assembling their team. They enlisted a Missouri firm, Krause & Kinsman, to help manage the anticipated volume and to have additional lawyers ready to fly into Louisiana. In an email that day titled “Hurricane Ida (and future hurricanes) Team,” MMA outlined how Krause & Kinsman would work on “data collection, automation, client communications,” etc., while Velawcity would serve as “marketing and intake specialist” charged with filtering and signing up clients. “(W)eed out clients that didn’t pass our criterion,” MMA instructed Velawcity bluntly.4 MMA was effectively outsourcing the first contact with clients — the marketing firm would identify qualified cases (homes with insurance, significant damage, etc.) and get them under contract.

    Velawcity deployed a sophisticated digital marketing campaign, targeting storm victims through social media, search ads, and third-party referrals. A homeowner might fill out an online form or call a number, thinking they were contacting a help center about an insurance claim. In reality, they reached Velawcity’s operators, who were trained to guide the person through a questionnaire. If the lead was promising, Velawcity wasted no time: clients report that they’d get an email via DocuSign, allowing them to sign an attorney-client agreement with MMA without ever speaking to an actual attorney. In one recorded call — later obtained in discovery — a Velawcity agent literally walked a confused homeowner click-by-click through signing the legal contract. The caller had not met or talked to any lawyer, but by the end of that call, MMA officially “represented” them.5

    Velawcity’s staff weren’t lawyers, and some had no background in insurance claims. According to deposition testimony, none of the people on the phones signing up MMA’s clients were licensed attorneys.6 To get around this, MMA instructed Velawcity’s team to introduce themselves as if they were employees of “McClenny Moseley & Associates.”7 This lent an aura of legitimacy to the solicitation: the clients thought they were dealing directly with a law firm’s intake department, not an outside sales center. Louisiana’s legal ethics rules strictly forbid non-lawyers from soliciting clients or giving legal advice, and they bar lawyers from paying others to send them cases. But what MMA and Velawcity arranged was essentially a modern workaround: Velawcity would do the solicitation under the lawyer’s branding, and MMA would pay Velawcity a hefty fee for each signed client.

    By all accounts, the scheme “worked” — at least initially. Velawcity signed up case after case. In a single day, they might enroll 50 or 100 new clients.8 By March 2022, internal communications reflected that Velawcity was delivering large volumes of new cases on a daily basis into their system.

    Storm waves explode into towering white spray under a gray sky
    02

    “The Hurricane Hustle” and Capping 2.0

    On December 13th, in 2022, Judge James D. Cain Jr. met with an attorney named R. William “Bill” Huye from his federal courtroom in Lake Charles, Louisiana.9 The lone Louisiana lawyer resided in a Texas-based firm that had inundated his docket with hurricane insurance cases.10

    In the past week, Huye’s firm — McClenny Moseley & Associates — had filed 1,629 lawsuits in a 48-hour span, a frantic rush before the legal deadline on Hurricane Laura claims, and was described by Judge Cain as a “mess.”11 The result was chaos: duplicate lawsuits, mix-ups and even cases filed on behalf of people who had cases that had already been dismissed in court.

    “I have some suits that I’ve already identified that have already been dismissed by this Court or they’ve settled and you filed another suit for them,” Judge Cain explained to Huye. “That is very troublesome to me because that, to me, gives me a lot of indication that there’s not been the adequate attorney-client communication because if you would have talked to these people you would know better.”12

    Judge Cain delivered a rebuke reflecting on the humanity behind the situation as well: “(T)his is not a mass tort settlement situation… (t)hese people are individuals,” he said, thumping on the fundamental duty of lawyers to know their clients. “Did you meet with them, did you talk to them, did you vet [them] out as officers of this court?”

    Huye tried to explain: “[I]f someone reaches out to MMA asking for a contract it would get directed to the advertiser who may manage the incoming call center, they would answer questions, they would collect some information and send the DocuSign contract to the client which the client would then review, decide if they do want to sign on and, if it signs on then they would come to me,” he said.13

    In essence, he admitted that a marketing outfit — not MMA’s lawyers — handled the entire intake and sign-up of clients. MMA’s attorneys often never spoke with a client until after a lawsuit was filed in that client’s name.

    The deal that powered the scale was stark in its simplicity: a per-client fee — once known as “capping” and illegal in Louisiana for decades. Contract exhibits describe a “Fixed Rate of $3,000 for each prescreened potential client reviewed for Law Firm and delivered to Law Firm,” later increased to a “Fixed Rate of $3,500.”14 Velawcity’s corporate representative confirmed in testimony that payment was per prescreened potential client delivered to MMA.15

    Whether you call it capping, running, or procurement, the core allegation is the same: the attorney-client relationship cannot be formed and delivered by a non-lawyer vendor for a bounty. That’s not just an ethics issue under Rule 7.4/7.2/5.5; in Louisiana, it intersects with criminal law under La. R.S. 37:219.

    Velawcity’s deposition confirmed that they did far more than place ads: they effectively ran MMA’s client communications and even helped draft legal documents.16 One internal Velawcity email to MMA shows a non-lawyer instructing MMA to put a line about “fee splits” back into the contract — evidence of potential fee-sharing with non-lawyers.17 Another exhibit was a script of FAQs MMA gave Velawcity to answer client questions, including telling clients they couldn’t get a copy of their own claim estimate — something virtually no real lawyer would say to their client without good reason.18

    Judge Cain realized this wasn’t just a case of sloppy lawyering — it was a systemic breakdown of legal ethics.

    Across the state, in New Orleans, Magistrate Judge Michael North was having a similar “aha” moment. In early 2023, he handled a case where MMA had filed suit on behalf of a woman who had already retained another attorney.19 Irate, Judge North summoned MMA’s lawyers. By February 1, 2023, he ordered MMA to cough up its Velawcity contracts and explain itself. Judge North’s findings, issued March 16, 2023, pulled no punches: MMA, he found, had “violated multiple ethical rules and, quite possibly, Louisiana law” and found MMA’s denials and obfuscations about the arrangement to be intentionally misleading — in plain terms, he said MMA’s attorneys lied about their “scheme.”20 In a particularly fiery passage, Judge North likened MMA’s operation to an invasive species in the legal ecosystem, declaring that MMA was “nothing less than a scourge on this State and its citizens, the Court, and the Bar.”21

    These judicial actions effectively halted MMA’s Louisiana campaign. After Judge North’s ruling, all of MMA’s Louisiana-licensed attorneys resigned from the firm and withdrew from every case. Bar disciplinary proceedings were coming soon.22 And MMA’s thousands of clients suddenly had no lawyer of record. This could have been a catastrophe for those homeowners — except other firms swooped in to take over. One of the most prominent was Morris Bart, LLC, a firm well-known in Louisiana (with ubiquitous local TV ads) and staffed to handle high volumes. Starting in April 2023, Morris Bart’s firm signed up many ex-MMA clients, assuring them that their cases would continue. Firms like Daly & Black (a Houston firm with a Louisiana office) and Galindo Law did the same. In effect, the “MMA clients” were absorbed into the inventories of established firms.

    This handoff solved one problem (clients getting representation) but created another: Who, if anyone, would pay MMA for the work it initiated on these cases?

    Four palm trees bend hard in hurricane winds against a gray sky
    03

    Hedge Fund in the Courtroom

    On April 9, 2024, MMA filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in the Southern District of Texas. This would turn out to be a tactical gambit with profound consequences. Bankruptcy can serve as a shield and a sword: it halted any lawsuits against MMA (including those inevitable investor suits and potential class actions by former clients), and it gave MMA a new venue (a federal bankruptcy court in Houston) to assert control over its remaining assets. And MMA argued that one major asset remained: the contingent fee contracts for those thousands of hurricane cases. Even if MMA wasn’t actively litigating them, the firm claimed a financial stake in them.

    It initiated an adversary proceeding (a lawsuit within the bankruptcy) against Morris Bart, LLC. MMA alleged that by settling cases for MMA’s former clients without paying MMA, Bart was essentially stealing estate property and violating the bankruptcy automatic stay (which protects the debtor’s assets). MMA asked the Houston bankruptcy judge for a preliminary injunction to force Bart to set aside 33% of any settlement proceeds (something they previously said they would not request)23 plus any case costs MMA had fronted, in a trust account until the court decided who was entitled to that money. In July 2024, that injunction was granted. Overnight, the dynamic changed: Morris Bart’s firm, which had been disbursing settlement checks to happy clients, now had to hold one-third of every dollar in escrow, waiting to see if MMA would successfully claim its cut. By this move, MMA staked a claim potentially worth tens of millions. It was a gutsy, even stunning move — essentially asking a Texas court to overrule what Louisiana judges had already said (that MMA’s contracts were void and waived).24

    Morris Bart’s reaction was, unsurprisingly, fierce. His legal team sought to dissolve the injunction, to transfer the case back to Louisiana, to dismiss MMA’s claims — anything to get out of the Houston courtroom. They pointed out that MMA had told the Eastern District of Louisiana it wouldn’t pursue fees, and that a judge in Louisiana had relied on that to declare MMA’s rights waived. MMA’s rejoinder: circumstances had changed. In the bankruptcy court, MMA argued it had a fiduciary duty to maximize assets for creditors (chief among them, the litigation funders who fronted the cash for Velawcity).25 The implication was that MMA had to pursue those fees now — or else its Wall Street backers would be left holding the bag. Indeed, those investors were a driving force. MMA’s bankruptcy filings reveal that an entity called Equal Access Justice Fund (EAJF) and a related fund had poured tens of millions of dollars into MMA’s hurricane venture. In exchange, they reportedly had liens on MMA’s case recoveries.

    A storm-damaged commercial building with a torn roof beneath leaning utility poles and slack power lines

    Moseley admitted in his April 2025 deposition that MMA had paid Velawcity approximately $33.5 million in total. When pressed on where a relatively small firm got $33 million, he acknowledged “in almost all cases, it came from EAJF.”26 In other words, MMA itself didn’t have the cash — its litigation funder financed the entire client acquisition spree. This was a business venture through and through.

    So, when MMA’s Louisiana house of cards collapsed, EAJF and others sued MMA to claw back their money. They even sought to intervene in the disciplinary actions, essentially saying: if MMA can’t collect fees, we (the investors) can’t be repaid — so let us be heard. It’s an extraordinary subplot: hedge-fund-type investors entangled in a legal ethics scandal, trying to protect their investment.

    In May 2025, Morris Bart’s attorneys filed a potent motion for summary judgment in the Houston court. At the time this article was submitted for publication, the Houston judge had not yet ruled and representatives for MMA did not respond to an email request for an interview.27

    Legal experts are divided on the outcome. On one hand, contracts arising from unethical or illegal arrangements are generally unenforceable — so logic suggests MMA will not collect a penny. On the other, bankruptcy courts have been known to approve creative settlements to avoid protracted fights. And MMA’s creditors (the investors) wield significant influence in the Chapter 11 case. Indeed, in late 2023 MMA reached a tentative settlement with those funders to resolve how to repay them. Part of that deal involved MMA selling its entire inventory of remaining mass-tort cases (over 6,000 of them, unrelated to the hurricanes) to another firm, and using proceeds to pay the funders. The funders, in turn, agreed to put on hold some of their actions against MMA’s principals.28 But when MMA’s principal, Moseley, didn’t exit the stage quietly, the funders renewed pressure — attempting in mid-2025 to haul him into Texas state court on what appears to be personal liability for the loans.29

    A raised house wrecked by a hurricane, its stairs and porch splintered, as workers on a ladder repair the roof
    04

    The Future That Is and Wasn’t

    The MMA saga is a stark reminder that age-old legal ethics can trip up modern, techno-enabled business plans. Signing up clients en masse through call centers and digital marketing might seem efficient — and indeed, MMA’s model was heralded by some as the future of mass torts: high volume, high tech, financed by big capital. But the legal profession draws bright lines: no soliciting clients with money or promises, no sharing fees with non-lawyers, and no outsourcing legal judgment to unsupervised staff. MMA, in its rush for growth, crossed all of those lines.

    How far will outside investors and aggressive lawyers push the envelope to capture lucrative litigation? In MMA’s case, the envelope was pushed beyond breaking, and the pushback — from judges, from the FBI (which has an open investigation),30 and from the organized bar — has been severe.

    The case also spotlights the role of court oversight in policing the plaintiff side of mass torts. Much attention is often paid to mass tort defendants (like Big Pharma or Big Oil) playing fast and loose; here, it was the plaintiffs’ lawyers under the microscope. Judges Cain and North, by demanding transparency (like the production of the Velawcity contracts) and holding hearings, likely prevented further abuse. They dragged a shadowy practice into the light.

    Now, bar associations in multiple states are reportedly examining tightening rules around lead generators and referral fees in the wake of MMA.31

    And for the thousands of homeowners who unwittingly got caught in this saga, most have transitioned to other more competent counsel to handle their cases, with MMA out of the picture (except as a footnote). However, at least one class action has been filed against MMA for allegedly fraudulent misrepresentation of clients — essentially, people claiming MMA filed lawsuits on their behalf without consent, harming their ability to resolve claims amicably. Those plaintiffs say MMA’s involvement, far from helping them, complicated and delayed their insurance recoveries.32

    In the end, the MMA affair might best be summed up by the frank astonishment expressed by Judge Cain at that pivotal hearing in late 2022. “If you would have talked to these people, you would know better,” he admonished MMA’s attorney. That simple principle — actually talking to your clients, one-on-one, attorney to client, to understand their case — was lost in MMA’s high-speed assembly line.

    Remember our friend Maria?

    She wasn’t asking or looking for a legal marketing sales funnel. She didn’t need a funding term sheet. She needed a plaintiff’s trial lawyer — one who knew her, her case, her story.

    The practice grows, or it doesn’t, on that distinction.

    Continue the story

    Hurricane Hustle, Part II

    Corrections

    This article was corrected on Nov. 13, 2026. The online version differs from the print edition in the following respects:

    • A recorded call described as a Velawcity agent walking “a confused homeowner” through signing was in fact a test call by Katherine Monson, the wife of Allied Trust’s counsel, according to sworn testimony (note 5).
    • An email about restoring a contract footer “for fee splits” concerned a fee split between MMA and its co-counsel, not with a non-lawyer (notes 3 and 17).
    • Magistrate Judge Michael North did not liken MMA to an invasive species; that comparison was ours (note 21). His order said MMA’s lawyers “lied,” but “intentionally misleading” was our phrase (note 20).
    • The article combined two hearings before Judge James D. Cain Jr., on Oct. 20 and Dec. 13, 2022, and misstated when the 1,629 lawsuits were filed (notes 9 and 11). Two quotations from the October hearing were also misquoted (note 12).
    • Quotations attributed to an Aug. 29, 2021 MMA email came from later deposition testimony (note 4).
    • Velawcity was delivering roughly 100 cases a day, not “50 or 100” (note 8). An FAQ advised clients that MMA did not recommend sending estimates; it did not say they could not get one (note 18).
    • The article omitted the Fifth Circuit’s June 2024 decision vacating Judge Cain’s order that MMA’s contracts were void (note 24).
    • The funders’ settlement with MMA was approved in May 2025, not reached in late 2023, and the sale of MMA’s mass-tort cases was proposed, not completed (note 28).
    • The class action described was a barratry suit over solicitation, not a suit over lawsuits filed without consent (note 32).

    Notes

    Numbered notes mark corrections, clarifications and developments since publication.

    1. Clarification: MMA began discussions with Velawcity in mid-2021, but the first written agreement in the court record was signed in December 2021. Velawcity’s first invoice, dated Dec. 6, 2021, billed $3 million for 1,000 retainers. Source: exhibits to Morris Bart LLC’s motion for summary judgment, MMA Law Firm, PLLC v. Morris Bart, LLC, S.D. Tex. No. 4:24-cv-04446, Docs. 19-2, 19-22 and 19-27 (cited below as “MSJ Ex.”).

      ↑ Back
    2. The “really good return rate” quote is from Velawcity’s Shane Radford, in an Aug. 19, 2021 email to MMA. The template MMA first supplied was another law firm’s one-page retainer form. Sources: MSJ Exs. 3 and 13.

      ↑ Back
    3. Correction: The “footer” in this email disclosed a fee-sharing arrangement between two law firms: 75% to McClenny Moseley & Associates and 25% to its co-counsel, Krause & Kinsman Trial Lawyers. It was not an arrangement to share fees with Velawcity or any other non-lawyer. The email, from Velawcity’s Phil Vottiero to MMA’s William Huye on Feb. 18, 2022, read: “I think we will need to have the footer added back in for fee splits.” The inference that Velawcity was arranging how legal fees would be shared was wrong. Source: MSJ Ex. 12.

      ↑ Back
    4. Correction: The Aug. 29, 2021 email, titled “Hurricane Ida (And future hurricanes) Team Intro Email,” lists Velawcity’s Phil Vottiero as “Marketing/ Intake Specialist.” The phrases “data collection, automation, client communications” and “(W)eed out clients that didn’t pass our criterion” are not in the email. They come from Zachary Moseley’s April 8, 2025 deposition testimony describing it, and Moseley later amended the “weed out” answer in an errata sheet. The email did not contain an instruction from MMA to Velawcity. Sources: MSJ Exs. 1 and 4.

      ↑ Back
    5. Correction: According to sworn testimony from Velawcity’s corporate representative, the recorded call described here was “a recording of Katherine Monson pretending to have a hurricane damage claim.” Ms. Monson is the wife of attorney Matthew Monson, who represented Allied Trust Insurance Co. in litigation involving MMA. The representative testified that the call followed Velawcity’s standard script. The caller was not a confused homeowner, and the call did not result in MMA representing anyone. The pull quote drawn from this passage in the print edition is not carried over. Source: MSJ Ex. 7 (deposition of Tighe Wilhelmy, Apr. 15, 2025), Tr. 135–138.

      ↑ Back
    6. Asked whether the employees conducting intake were Louisiana-licensed attorneys, Velawcity’s corporate representative testified: “To my knowledge there wasn’t any attorneys.” Source: MSJ Ex. 7, Tr. 49–50.

      ↑ Back
    7. Clarification: Emails in the court record show that Velawcity’s Shane Radford asked MMA on April 7, 2022 whether staff should say they worked “on behalf of” or “for” the firm. Huye replied that a script naming McClenny Moseley & Associates “makes the most sense,” and Radford answered, “We’ll script as we’re working for MMA.” Moseley has testified that he did not approve it. The record does not show that the script was adopted to get around the absence of lawyers. Sources: MSJ Exs. 1 and 9.

      ↑ Back
    8. Correction: The record supports a figure of roughly 100 a day, not “50 or 100.” On March 16, 2022, Velawcity’s Phil Vottiero wrote, “We are delivering roughly 100 new cases per day.” Moseley has testified that he did not know whether all of those were hurricane cases. The pull quote drawn from this passage in the print edition is not carried over. Source: MSJ Ex. 19.

      ↑ Back
    9. Correction: This section combines two hearings before Judge Cain. The hearing at which he discussed the 1,629 lawsuits, called the filings a “mess,” and made the remarks quoted below took place on Oct. 20, 2022. At that hearing he noted that the courtroom was not his own. Huye’s description of the intake process, quoted later in this section, came at a separate hearing on Dec. 13, 2022, in Green v. State Farm. Sources: hearing transcripts of Oct. 20, 2022 and Dec. 13, 2022, filed as MSJ Exs. 16 and 28.

      ↑ Back
    10. Correction: Huye was MMA’s lead Louisiana lawyer, not its only one. Grant Gardiner, also an MMA attorney, appeared with Huye at the Oct. 20, 2022 hearing, and MMA listed other Louisiana attorneys on its Hurricane Ida team. Sources: MSJ Exs. 4 and 16.

      ↑ Back
    11. Correction: Judge Cain referred to “1629 lawsuits in two days.” The filings were made in late August 2022, ahead of the deadline for Hurricane Laura claims, weeks before the Oct. 20 hearing, not in the week before it. Source: MSJ Ex. 16.

      ↑ Back
    12. Correction: The hearing transcript reads “already been either dismissed by this Court” and “client-attorney communication.” Source: MSJ Ex. 16, Tr. 15.

      ↑ Back
    13. Huye made these remarks at the Dec. 13, 2022 hearing (see note 9). In the same exchange he told the court, “There are some instances whenever it’s through an advertiser we have our ethics counsel review the process.” Asked by Judge Cain, “So you’re paying per contract?” Huye answered, “No, sir. Absolutely not … It’s unethical.” Velawcity’s contracts with MMA, quoted below, set a fixed rate for each prescreened potential client. Source: MSJ Ex. 28, Tr. 101–102.

      ↑ Back
    14. The December 2021 agreement provides that MMA would “pre-pay Velawcity a Fixed Rate of $3,000.00 for each prescreened potential client reviewed for Law Firm and delivered to Law Firm.” The $3,500 rate appears in the April 2022 agreement. Magistrate Judge Michael North found that MMA paid Velawcity $13,938,000 for some 4,268 cases in less than a year. Sources: MSJ Exs. 22 and 24; Franatovich v. Allied Trust Ins. Co., E.D. La. No. 2:22-cv-02552, Doc. 76.

      ↑ Back
    15. “Q. Was Velawcity paid per prescreened potential client that it provided to MMA? A. Yes.” Source: MSJ Ex. 7, Tr. 28.

      ↑ Back
    16. Clarification: The record shows that Velawcity ran customer-service scripts and FAQs for MMA’s clients and suggested edits to MMA’s contract forms. It does not show Velawcity drafting legal documents. Sources: MSJ Exs. 7 and 13.

      ↑ Back
    17. Correction: See note 3. The “fee splits” line concerned a split between MMA and its co-counsel, not with a non-lawyer, and the email was phrased as a suggestion (“I think we will need …”), not an instruction.

      ↑ Back
    18. Correction: The FAQ did not tell clients they could not get their estimate. It read, in part: “We do not typically send the estimates to clients because it often times creates confusion and false expectations … we do not recommend sending you a copy.” Source: MSJ Ex. 15.

      ↑ Back
    19. The case was Franatovich v. Allied Trust Insurance Co., E.D. La. No. 2:22-cv-02552. MMA’s involvement arose through a roofing company, not Velawcity. Allied Trust was represented by Matthew Monson of the Monson Law Firm. Judge North’s sanctions against MMA included $26,138.31 payable to the Monson Law Firm, $4,875 to the plaintiff’s counsel, Broussard + Williamson, and $500 to Ms. Franatovich. In April 2026, MMA’s bankruptcy estate sued Monson and Allied Trust, alleging among other things improper ex parte contacts between Monson and Judge North. Those allegations have not been proven; see Part 2. Sources: Franatovich, Docs. 72 and 76; MMA Law Firm, PLLC v. Monson, Bankr. S.D. Tex. Adv. No. 26-03107.

      ↑ Back
    20. Clarification: The “violated multiple ethical rules” passage refers to MMA’s arrangement with Velawcity. “Intentionally misleading” is our characterization, not Judge North’s phrase; his order is more direct. He wrote that “Moseley lied to me,” that “Huye lied in open court,” and that “what these lawyers lied about was their scheme to use an outside non-lawyer to directly solicit prospective clients and to obtain written contingency-fee contracts … before the ‘client’ ever spoke with a lawyer associated with MMA, much less any lawyer.” Source: Franatovich, Doc. 76 at 20–23.

      ↑ Back
    21. Correction: Judge North did not liken MMA to an invasive species. That comparison was ours and should not have been attributed to him. The “scourge” quotation is accurate; Judge North applied it to “William Huye, Zach Moseley, and McClenny, Moseley & Associates.” The pull quote drawn from this passage in the print edition is not carried over. Source: Franatovich, Doc. 76 at 26.

      ↑ Back
    22. Clarification: The Louisiana Supreme Court had already placed Huye on interim suspension on March 3, 2023, before Judge North’s March 16 order (In re Huye, No. 2023-B-00277). According to the record, MMA’s Louisiana-licensed attorneys resigned and withdrew from the cases they had filed for Hurricane Ida claimants. Sources: MSJ Ex. 31; MMA Law Firm v. Morris Bart, Doc. 41.

      ↑ Back
    23. Clarification: In a March 15, 2024 filing in the Eastern District of Louisiana, MMA said it did not intend to intervene in cases pending there to seek attorneys’ fees or costs, but it reserved claims against successor firms. The bankruptcy court entered the preliminary injunction on July 15, 2024. Source: MMA Law Firm v. Morris Bart, Doc. 41.

      ↑ Back
    24. Correction: This passage omitted a ruling that came well before this article went to print. Judge Cain’s Aug. 22, 2023 order declared that MMA’s “clear solicitation of clients voids any contract of representation.” On June 7, 2024, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit vacated that order because MMA had not been given notice or an opportunity to be heard; the court did not reach the merits. Magistrate Judge North’s April 2024 finding that MMA waived fees in Eastern District of Louisiana cases was not affected; see note 27. Source: McClenny Moseley & Assocs. v. Equal Access Justice Fund, 5th Cir. Nos. 23-30670 and 23-30692 (June 7, 2024).

      ↑ Back
    25. Clarification: In its bankruptcy filings, MMA said it “has continued to meet its fiduciary obligations, preserve and protect estate assets,” and that its plan would be funded chiefly by pursuing fee claims against other law firms. “Circumstances had changed” is our paraphrase; Morris Bart described the same shift as MMA having “changed its tune” once it could litigate outside Louisiana. Sources: Debtor’s Disclosure Statement, In re MMA Law Firm, PLLC, Bankr. S.D. Tex. No. 24-31596, Doc. 692 (June 13, 2025); MSJ (Doc. 19).

      ↑ Back
    26. Moseley gave the $33.5 million figure as “a total in my head of payments that were issued to Velawcity,” while being questioned about whether MMA had paid specific invoices. Pressed on whether MMA itself made the payments, he testified that MMA was responsible for “a majority, if not all” of them, but “the money could have come from other places. … In almost all cases, it came from EAJF.” MMA filed the transcript of the April 8, 2025 deposition as an exhibit in the Morris Bart case. Magistrate Judge North’s court-documented figure covers less than a year: $13,938,000 for some 4,268 cases. Sources: MMA Law Firm v. Morris Bart, Doc. 24-13, Tr. 215–216; Franatovich, Doc. 76.

      ↑ Back
    27. Update: On Jan. 23, 2026, U.S. District Judge Andrew S. Hanen granted Morris Bart’s motion in part, holding that MMA “voluntarily and knowingly waived” its right to collect attorneys’ fees or costs in cases pending in the Eastern District of Louisiana on or before March 15, 2024, with two exceptions. MMA has appealed to the Fifth Circuit (No. 26-20046). Judge Hanen also certified questions of Louisiana law to the Louisiana Supreme Court, which answered on June 29, 2026 that a fee contract procured through unethical or illegal conduct is absolutely null, with no recovery of fees, including on a quantum meruit basis. That court made no findings about MMA’s conduct. The Houston case was stayed in March 2026 pending the appeal and the certification. In April 2026, MMA’s bankruptcy estate sued Allied Trust Insurance Co. and attorney Matthew Monson; see Part 2. Sources: MMA Law Firm v. Morris Bart, Docs. 41 and 61; In re MMA Law Firm, La. No. 2026-CQ-00161.

      ↑ Back
    28. Correction: The settlement between MMA and its funders, Equal Access Justice Fund and EAJF ESQ, was reached in MMA’s bankruptcy case and approved by the court in May 2025, not in late 2023. Under MMA’s proposed plan, the funders would receive 37.5% of the proceeds from any sale of MMA’s four mass-tort dockets, about 6,100 cases involving Zantac, Tylenol, Roundup and NEC. MMA described that sale as potential, not completed. Sources: Bankr. S.D. Tex. No. 24-31596, Doc. 692 at 5–6 and 20–21; Doc. 706.

      ↑ Back
    29. Clarification: Equal Access Justice Fund sued MMA and Moseley in Harris County district court in 2023, including on Moseley’s personal guarantee (Cause No. 2023-59211). In June 2025, weeks after the bankruptcy settlement, the funder set its motion for summary judgment against Moseley personally for submission on July 14, 2025; MMA said the motion sought more than $36 million. MMA then asked the bankruptcy court to extend its stay of litigation to protect him. Sources: Notice of Submission, Harris County No. 2023-59211 (June 23, 2025); Bankr. S.D. Tex. No. 24-31596, Doc. 706 (June 26, 2025).

      ↑ Back
    30. Update: On Aug. 28, 2026, federal prosecutors in New Orleans charged Richard William Huye III, MMA’s former lead Louisiana lawyer, by bill of information with one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud. The charging document refers to MMA as “Law Firm A” and to an unnamed founding partner as “Co-Conspirator 1.” The U.S. Attorney’s Office credited the FBI’s investigation. A charge is not a finding of guilt. As of late October 2026 Huye had not entered a plea, and his hearings had been continued without a date. See Part 2. Source: United States v. Huye, E.D. La. No. 2:26-cr-00198.

      ↑ Back
    31. Update: Since this article went to print, several states have moved to restrict outside ownership of law firms and fee-sharing arrangements, among them California (2025), Colorado and Illinois (2026). Arizona tightened its licensing rules for nonlawyer-owned firms in March 2026. See Part 2.

      ↑ Back
    32. Correction: The class action, filed in federal court in Houston by Katherine Monson (S.D. Tex. No. 4:23-cv-00928), was brought under the Texas barratry statute over MMA’s solicitation of clients. It did not allege that MMA filed lawsuits without consent. The case was pending when this article went to print, and on Oct. 1, 2025 it was dismissed with prejudice on the ground that the Texas barratry statute does not reach solicitation outside Texas. Individual homeowners have separately alleged that MMA represented them without authorization; one such suit is described in the federal charge discussed in note 30.

      ↑ Back

    Eugene Henderson

    Contributor · Trial Lawyer’s Journal

    Discover Next

    Insights from PI Experts

    Learn from experts in personal injury about key cases, the business of law, and more insights that shape the future of trial law.

    Author