Skip to main content

The Trial Lawyer's Journal

TLJ Small Logo
Close
Group 39053677
Share Your Story with Trial Lawyer’s Journal
Trial Lawyer’s Journal is built on the voices of trial lawyers like you. Share your journey, insights, and experiences through articles, interviews, and our podcast, Celebrating Justice.
Stay Updated
Sign up for our newsletter to get the latest from TLJ.



    What Is an Answer in a Lawsuit?

    What Is an Answer in a Lawsuit?

    An answer is the defendant’s formal written response to a civil complaint, filed under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. In it, the defendant admits or denies each allegation, states any affirmative defenses and may assert counterclaims. The answer joins the issues for litigation and is generally due within 21 days of service of the summons and complaint.

    This article explains the purpose of an answer, how a defendant admits or denies allegations under Rule 8(b), when the pleading is due under Rule 12(a) and what a defendant may include beyond simple denials. The goal is a clear, practitioner-level map of the pleading that frames every civil case.

    What Is the Purpose of an Answer in a Lawsuit?

    The purpose of an answer is to respond to the plaintiff‘s allegations and to define which facts are genuinely disputed. By admitting some allegations and denying others, the defendant narrows the case to the contested issues, sparing the parties and the court the burden of litigating matters everyone agrees on. The answer is the defendant’s first substantive pleading and the counterpart to the complaint that opened the case.

    An answer serves a second, equally important function: it preserves defenses. A defendant who fails to plead certain matters in the answer risks waiving them, so the pleading is where the defense strategy first takes concrete form. In many cases the defendant files an answer only after any pre-answer motions are resolved, since a Rule 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss must ordinarily precede the responsive pleading.

    • The answer responds allegation by allegation to the complaint.
    • It narrows the litigation to the facts actually in dispute.
    • It preserves defenses that would otherwise be waived.
    • It is typically filed after any pre-answer motion is decided.

    How Does a Defendant Admit or Deny Allegations Under Rule 8(b)?

    Rule 8(b) requires the defendant to admit or deny each allegation and to state in short, plain terms the defenses to each claim. For every numbered paragraph of the complaint, the defendant must either admit it, deny it, or state that it lacks knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief about its truth — a response that operates as a denial. Precision matters, because an allegation that is not denied, other than one about the amount of damages, is deemed admitted.

    The rule permits several forms of denial to fit the situation. A general denial rejects every allegation at once and is appropriate only when the defendant genuinely contests all of them, including jurisdiction. Far more common is the specific denial, in which the defendant answers each paragraph individually and the partial denial, in which the defendant admits part of an allegation and denies the rest. A defendant must not deny in bad faith what it knows to be true.

    • Admit: the defendant concedes the allegation is accurate.
    • Deny: the defendant contests the allegation, placing it in issue.
    • Lack of knowledge: treated as a denial where the defendant cannot truthfully admit or deny.
    • Failure to respond: an unanswered allegation, except as to damages, is deemed admitted under Rule 8(b)(6).

    What Is the Deadline to File an Answer?

    Under Rule 12(a), a defendant served with a summons and complaint generally must serve an answer within 21 days after service. That baseline deadline shifts in defined situations: a defendant who timely waives formal service under Rule 4(d) receives 60 days from the date the waiver request was sent, or 90 days if served outside the United States, and the United States and its agencies and officers ordinarily have 60 days. Missing the deadline exposes the defendant to a default judgment.

    A pending pre-answer motion also alters the clock. When a defendant files a Rule 12 motion, Rule 12(a)(4) suspends the time to answer until the court acts; if the motion is denied or postponed, the responsive pleading is generally due within 14 days after notice of the court’s action. Because these intervals are set by rule and can be extended by stipulation or court order, counsel should calendar the specific deadline rather than assume the 21-day default.

    SituationTime to answer
    Standard service of summons and complaint21 days after service
    Waiver of service within the United States60 days from waiver request sent
    Waiver of service outside the United States90 days from waiver request sent
    United States, its agencies or officers60 days
    After denial of a Rule 12 motionGenerally 14 days after notice of the ruling

    What Can a Defendant Include Beyond Denials?

    Beyond admitting and denying, a defendant may assert affirmative defenses and claims of its own in the same pleading. Rule 8(c) directs the defendant to state affirmatively any avoidance or affirmative defense — such as a release, the statute of limitations or comparative fault — because such defenses concede the allegations yet offer a legal reason the defendant should still prevail. Defenses not pleaded may be forfeited, so the answer is the moment to raise them.

    The answer can also carry the defendant’s own claims. A defendant may plead a counterclaim against the plaintiff under Rule 13 or a cross-claim against a co-party, and may bring in a new party through a third-party complaint under Rule 14. These devices let related disputes be resolved together rather than in separate suits, and the compulsory-counterclaim rule may require certain claims to be raised now or lost.

    1. Denials that place the plaintiff’s allegations in dispute.
    2. Affirmative defenses stated under Rule 8(c) to defeat or limit liability.
    3. Counterclaims against the plaintiff, whether compulsory or permissive, under Rule 13.
    4. Cross-claims against co-parties and third-party claims under Rules 13(g) and 14.

    State practice varies on several of these points. Many states track the federal answer closely, but deadlines, the availability of a general denial and the consequences of an unpleaded defense differ by jurisdiction, so practitioners should confirm the local rule before relying on the federal framework.

    Conclusion

    An answer in a lawsuit is the defendant’s formal response to the complaint: it admits or denies each allegation under Rule 8(b), raises affirmative defenses under Rule 8(c), and may assert counterclaims and cross-claims, all within the 21-day default deadline set by Rule 12(a). The pleading defines the disputed issues and preserves defenses that silence would waive. Because filing deadlines and pleading conventions vary between the federal system and the states, counsel should calendar the exact response date and confirm the governing procedural rule in the forum.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    How long does a defendant have to file an answer?

    Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(a), a defendant generally has 21 days after being served with the summons and complaint to serve an answer. That period expands to 60 days when the defendant waives formal service within the United States, 90 days when service is waived abroad, and 60 days for the United States and its officers. Filing a Rule 12 motion suspends the deadline until the court rules, after which the answer is usually due within 14 days.

    If a defendant fails to answer or otherwise respond within the deadline, the plaintiff may seek entry of default and then a default judgment under Rule 55. A default treats the well-pleaded allegations of liability as admitted, though the plaintiff may still need to prove the amount of damages. Courts can set aside a default for good cause, but a defendant should never rely on that possibility instead of responding on time.

    An answer responds to the merits of the complaint by admitting or denying its allegations, while a motion to dismiss asks the court to end the case on a threshold ground without a merits response. The two are sequenced by rule: a defendant who files a Rule 12 motion need not answer until the motion is decided. If the motion is denied, the defendant then files an answer within the time the rule allows.

    Yes. Beyond denials and affirmative defenses, a defendant may assert counterclaims against the plaintiff under Rule 13 and cross-claims against co-parties under Rule 13(g), and may bring in a new party by third-party complaint under Rule 14. Compulsory counterclaims — those arising from the same transaction or occurrence as the plaintiff’s claim — generally must be raised in the answer or are lost, so the pleading is the place to assert related claims.

    Discover Next

    Insights from PI Experts

    Learn from experts in personal injury about key cases, the business of law, and more insights that shape the future of trial law.

    Author