The Trial Lawyer's Journal

TLJ Small Logo
Close
Group 39053677
Share Your Story with Trial Lawyer’s Journal
Trial Lawyer’s Journal is built on the voices of trial lawyers like you. Share your journey, insights, and experiences through articles, interviews, and our podcast, Celebrating Justice.
Contribute
Stay Updated
Sign up for our newsletter to get the latest from TLJ.



    {01}
    Podcasts
    Season 1
    Season 2
    {02}
    Print Editions
    No. 01
    No. 02
    No. 03
    {03}
    Articles
    {04}
    Our Story
    {04}
    Join
    Explore Membership
    {05}
    Contact
    Follow

    Category: Glossary

    Posted on

    What is Guardian ad Litem?

    What is Guardian ad Litem?

    What is a guardian ad litem in personal injury law?

    A guardian ad litem (GAL) is a person appointed by the court to represent the best interests of a child or legally incompetent adult during a lawsuit. In personal injury cases, a GAL may be appointed to make legal decisions, approve settlements, and ensure the protected person’s rights are fully safeguarded. The GAL acts independently from the parties in the case and must report to the court about what outcome best serves the individual they represent. This role helps ensure that vulnerable parties have an advocate focused solely on their welfare.

    • Court-appointed representative for vulnerable individuals.

    • Acts in best interests of child or incapacitated adult.

    • Common in personal injury settlements.

    • Independent from other parties.

    When is a guardian ad litem appointed?

    A GAL is typically appointed when a minor is involved in a lawsuit, or when an adult is deemed legally incompetent due to injury, illness, or disability. This can happen at the start of a case or when it becomes clear that the person cannot make informed decisions. The GAL steps in to participate in legal proceedings, communicate with attorneys, and help the court evaluate settlements.

    • For minors in lawsuits.

    • For legally incapacitated adults.

    • Appointed early in litigation or as needed.

    • Helps court assess settlement fairness.

    Why is a guardian ad litem important?

    Without a GAL, vulnerable parties might be pressured into unfair settlements or fail to understand complex legal issues affecting their rights. The GAL ensures that decisions made during litigation truly benefit the person they represent and comply with court requirements. They also provide a written report to the judge detailing their recommendations.

    • Protects against unfair settlements.

    • Ensures rights are upheld.

    • Provides objective, court-guided advocacy.

    • Strengthens judicial oversight.

    What authority does a guardian ad litem have?

    The GAL can investigate facts, review evidence, and consult with experts to determine what serves the person’s best interests. They may also negotiate on the person’s behalf, recommend or reject settlement offers, and testify in court about their findings. However, their authority is limited to the scope defined by the court’s appointment order.

    • Can investigate and gather facts.

    • May recommend or reject settlements.

    • Can testify in court about best interests.

    • Powers limited to court’s instructions.

    Conclusion:
     A guardian ad litem is a safeguard in the legal system that ensures minors and legally incompetent adults are represented fairly and their interests are fully protected in personal injury cases.

    What is a guardian ad litem?

    A court-appointed representative who protects the best interests of a minor or legally incompetent adult during a lawsuit.

    Not necessarily — some are lawyers, but others may be trained advocates appointed to act in the person’s best interests.

    Costs may be paid by the parties involved, covered by the court, or deducted from the settlement.

    Yes — but the court must ultimately approve it.

    Additional Articles

    Explore All Articles
    [eac_elementor_tmpl id="1476"]
    Posted on

    What is Premises Liability?

    What is Premises Liability?

    What is premises liability in personal injury law?

    Premises liability is the legal responsibility of property owners and occupiers to maintain safe conditions for visitors. If someone is injured because of a dangerous condition on the property, the owner may be held liable if they knew or should have known about the hazard.

    • Responsibility for safe property conditions.

       

    • Applies to owners and occupiers.

       

    • Covers slip and falls, unsafe structures, poor lighting, etc.

       

    • Requires knowledge or reasonable awareness of hazard.

       

    When does premises liability apply?

    It applies when a person is lawfully on the property and is injured due to unsafe conditions the owner failed to fix or warn about. In some cases, it may also apply to trespassers, especially children under the “attractive nuisance” doctrine.

    • Covers lawful visitors and sometimes trespassing children.

       

    • Requires failure to fix or warn of hazards.

       

    • Hazards include spills, broken steps, poor security, etc.

       

    • Standards vary by state law.

       

    Why is premises liability important for injury victims?

    It ensures that property owners are held accountable for unsafe environments and that victims can recover damages for their injuries. This encourages better maintenance and safety standards.

    • Promotes safe property upkeep.

       

    • Helps victims recover damages.

       

    • Encourages proactive safety measures.

       

    • Holds owners accountable.

       

    What are examples of premises liability cases?

    Common examples include slip-and-fall accidents in stores, injuries from falling objects, swimming pool accidents, and inadequate security leading to assaults.

    • Slip and falls on wet floors.

       

    • Falling merchandise in stores.

       

    • Swimming pool accidents.

       

    • Inadequate lighting or security.

       

    Conclusion:
     Premises liability protects visitors by holding property owners responsible for maintaining safe conditions. It’s a key part of personal injury law aimed at preventing avoidable accidents.

    What is premises liability?

    It’s the legal duty of property owners to maintain safe conditions for visitors.

    Yes — in many cases, tenants or occupiers share responsibility for safety.

    Sometimes — especially if a child is injured due to an attractive nuisance.

    Yes — actual or constructive knowledge is usually required.

    Additional Articles

    Explore All Articles
    [eac_elementor_tmpl id="1476"]
    Posted on

    What is Dram Shop Liability?

    What is Dram Shop Liability?

    What is dram shop liability in personal injury law?

    Dram shop liability is a legal doctrine that holds bars, restaurants, and other establishments that serve alcohol responsible if they sell or serve alcohol to an obviously intoxicated person (or sometimes a minor) who then causes injury or death. The name comes from old “dram shops” that sold spirits by the dram, a small unit of measure.

    • Holds alcohol sellers accountable for overserving.

       

    • Applies to intoxicated patrons who cause harm.

       

    • Often covers sales to minors.

       

    • Based on state dram shop laws.

       

    When does dram shop liability apply?

    It applies when a licensed establishment serves alcohol to a visibly intoxicated person or a minor, and that person causes injury — often in a drunk driving accident. Laws vary by state, with some imposing strict liability and others requiring proof of negligence.

    • Serving visibly intoxicated patrons.

       

    • Selling to underage customers.

       

    • Harm caused soon after alcohol service.

       

    • Rules vary by jurisdiction.

       

    Why is dram shop liability important?

    It creates accountability for businesses that profit from alcohol sales and helps reduce the dangers of overserving. For victims, it provides an additional source of compensation beyond the intoxicated person who caused the harm.

    • Encourages responsible alcohol service.

       

    • Offers additional compensation sources.

       

    • Deters overserving intoxicated people.

       

    • Protects public safety.

       

    Are there limits to dram shop liability?

    Yes. Many states limit liability to cases where the service was to a visibly intoxicated person or a minor. Some states cap damages or require proof that the alcohol service was a direct cause of the harm.

    • Service must be to intoxicated or underage patrons.

       

    • May require direct causation proof.

       

    • Some states cap damages.

       

    • Laws vary widely.

       

    Conclusion:
     Dram shop liability laws protect the public by holding alcohol-serving businesses accountable when overserving leads to preventable tragedies.

    What is dram shop liability?

     It’s the legal responsibility of alcohol-serving establishments for harm caused by overserving intoxicated patrons or serving minors.

    Most states have dram shop laws, but the rules vary widely.

    In some states, yes — especially if they serve alcohol to minors.

    Usually yes — often based on visible signs of impairment.

    Additional Articles

    Explore All Articles
    [eac_elementor_tmpl id="1476"]
    Posted on

    What is Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress?

    What is Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress?

    What is intentional infliction of emotional distress in personal injury law?

    Intentional infliction of emotional distress (IIED) is a legal claim that arises when someone’s extreme and outrageous conduct intentionally or recklessly causes another person severe emotional harm. It focuses on emotional and psychological injuries rather than physical harm.

    • Covers severe emotional injuries.

    • Requires extreme and outrageous conduct.

    • Defendant must act intentionally or recklessly.

    • Common in harassment or abuse cases.

    What must be proven for IIED?

    Generally, the plaintiff must prove:
     (1) the defendant’s conduct was extreme and outrageous,
     (2) the conduct was intentional or reckless,
     (3) the conduct caused severe emotional distress, and
     (4) the distress is supported by credible evidence.

    • Extreme and outrageous conduct.

    • Intentional or reckless behavior.

    • Causal link to emotional harm.

    • Evidence of severe distress.

    What are examples of IIED?

    Examples include severe workplace harassment, stalking, public humiliation, or threats of serious harm. The behavior must go beyond mere rudeness or insults — it must be shocking and intolerable in a civilized society.

    • Harassment causing trauma.

    • Threats of serious harm.

    • Stalking or intimidation.

    • Humiliation that’s extreme.

    Why is IIED important in personal injury cases?

    It allows victims to recover damages for emotional suffering even when there’s no physical injury. Proving IIED can also open the door to punitive damages in extreme cases.

    • Provides compensation for emotional harm.

    • Can lead to punitive damages.

    • Protects victims from severe mistreatment.

    • Recognizes mental health impacts of abuse.

    Conclusion:
     Intentional infliction of emotional distress holds people accountable for extreme conduct that causes serious emotional harm, even without physical injury.

    What is intentional infliction of emotional distress?

    It’s a claim for damages when someone’s extreme, outrageous conduct causes severe emotional harm.

    No — IIED focuses on emotional harm, though evidence of distress is needed.

    It must be so outrageous that it’s intolerable in a civilized society.

    Yes — in cases of extreme and malicious conduct.

    Additional Articles

    Explore All Articles
    [eac_elementor_tmpl id="1476"]
    Posted on

    What is Negligent Security?

    What is Negligent Security?

    What is negligent security in personal injury law?

    Negligent security is a type of premises liability claim that arises when a property owner or business fails to provide reasonable security measures, resulting in a visitor being harmed by criminal activity. The idea is that the property owner should have foreseen the risk and taken steps to prevent it.

    • Part of premises liability law.

       

    • Involves failure to provide reasonable security.

       

    • Applies to criminal acts by third parties.

       

    • Requires foreseeable risk of harm.

       

    When does negligent security apply?

    It applies when there’s a history of crime in the area or other warning signs that make criminal activity foreseeable. Common examples include attacks in poorly lit parking lots, assaults in hotels with broken locks, or robberies at apartment complexes with no security patrols.

    • Prior criminal incidents in area.

       

    • Poor lighting or broken locks.

       

    • No security personnel in high-risk areas.

       

    • Failure to respond to known dangers.

       

    Why is negligent security important for victims?

    It provides a way to hold property owners accountable when their inaction contributes to violent crimes. For victims, it can help recover medical expenses, lost wages, and damages for pain and suffering.

    • Holds owners accountable for unsafe environments.

       

    • Encourages proactive crime prevention.

       

    • Helps victims recover compensation.

       

    • Improves public safety.

       

    What must be proven in negligent security cases?

    Plaintiffs generally must show that the property owner had a duty to provide security, failed to take reasonable steps to do so, and that this failure was a substantial factor in causing their injury.

    • Duty of care existed.

       

    • Security measures were inadequate.

       

    • Failure contributed to criminal attack.

       

    • Plaintiff suffered actual harm.

       

    Conclusion:
     Negligent security claims ensure that businesses and property owners take reasonable steps to protect visitors from foreseeable criminal acts.

    What is negligent security?

    It’s when a property owner fails to provide reasonable safety measures, leading to harm from criminal activity.

    No — only those that were foreseeable and preventable with reasonable measures.

    Apartment complexes, hotels, parking lots, and shopping centers.

    Lighting, locks, surveillance cameras, and security patrols, depending on the situation.

    Additional Articles

    Explore All Articles
    [eac_elementor_tmpl id="1476"]
    Posted on

    What is Loss of Household Services?

    What is Loss of Household Services?

    What is loss of household services in personal injury law?

    Loss of household services refers to the inability of an injured person to perform the daily tasks they used to handle at home, such as cooking, cleaning, childcare, yard work, and maintenance. This loss can be included in personal injury damages to cover the cost of hiring others to perform these services.

    • Covers domestic tasks the victim can no longer do.

    • Includes cooking, cleaning, childcare, yard work.

    • Part of personal injury damages.

    • Measured by replacement cost.

    Why is loss of household services compensated?

    Because these services have economic value. When an injury prevents someone from providing them, the household may need to hire outside help or rely on others, which represents a real loss.

    • Recognizes economic value of domestic work.

    • Compensates for hiring replacements.

    • Helps maintain household functioning.

    • Reflects hidden financial impacts of injury.

    How is the value of lost household services calculated?

    Courts and insurance companies estimate the number of hours of household work lost and multiply by the reasonable market rate for those services. This can be supported by testimony from the injured person, family, or vocational experts.

    • Based on hours lost × market rate.

    • Uses testimony and expert reports.

    • Adjusted for injury severity and recovery time.

    • May cover future losses.

    Can loss of household services be claimed long-term?

    Yes. In serious injury cases, these damages may extend for years or even a lifetime if the victim can never resume their previous household responsibilities.

    • Long-term in serious injury cases.

    • May cover permanent disability.

    • Included in lifetime care plans.

    • Can be significant damages component.

    Conclusion:
     Loss of household services damages recognize the real economic impact of losing the ability to manage one’s home, ensuring victims are fairly compensated.

    What is loss of household services?

    It’s the loss of the ability to perform household tasks due to injury, requiring replacement help.

    Yes — they address unpaid domestic work, not employment income.

    Not necessarily — testimony and expert valuation can be enough.

    Yes — but the value can still be calculated for damages purposes.

    Additional Articles

    Explore All Articles
    [eac_elementor_tmpl id="1476"]
    Posted on

    What is Spoliation of Evidence?

    What is Spoliation of Evidence?

    What is spoliation of evidence in personal injury law?

    Spoliation of evidence occurs when a party destroys, alters, or fails to preserve evidence that is relevant to a legal claim. This can happen accidentally or intentionally. In personal injury cases, it can harm the opposing party’s ability to prove their claim and may lead to serious legal consequences.

    • Involves destroying or altering important evidence.

       

    • Can be intentional or accidental.

       

    • Harms the other party’s ability to prove their case.

       

    • Has serious legal repercussions.

       

    Why is spoliation of evidence a big deal?

    Evidence is the foundation of any personal injury case. When it’s lost or destroyed, it can distort the truth, weaken claims, and prevent fair outcomes. Courts take spoliation seriously because it undermines the justice system.

    • Prevents the court from seeing the full truth.

       

    • Can severely weaken a case.

       

    • Undermines fairness in the legal process.

       

    • May result in sanctions or penalties.

       

    What are the consequences of spoliation?

    Courts can impose sanctions such as fines, dismissal of claims, or instructing the jury to assume the missing evidence would have been unfavorable to the party responsible for its loss. In extreme cases, spoliation can lead to criminal charges.

    • Fines and monetary penalties.

       

    • Case dismissal or claim limits.

       

    • Adverse inference jury instructions.

       

    • Potential criminal liability.

       

    How can spoliation be avoided?

    Once litigation is anticipated, parties must preserve all relevant evidence. This includes creating backups, storing physical evidence securely, and following legal preservation notices. Attorneys often send “litigation hold” letters to formalize this requirement.

    • Preserve evidence as soon as litigation is likely.

       

    • Follow litigation hold procedures.

       

    • Store items securely.

       

    • Keep digital backups.

       

    Conclusion:
     Spoliation of evidence can damage or even destroy a personal injury case. Preserving relevant evidence is both a legal duty and a smart strategy.

    What is spoliation of evidence?

    It’s the destruction, alteration, or loss of evidence relevant to a legal claim.

    Yes — but courts may still impose penalties.

    Courts may sanction the responsible party or instruct the jury to assume the evidence was unfavorable.

    They issue “litigation hold” letters and take steps to preserve evidence.

    Additional Articles

    Explore All Articles
    [eac_elementor_tmpl id="1476"]
    Posted on

    What is Expert Witness Designation?

    What is Expert Witness Designation?

    What is expert witness designation in personal injury law?

    Expert witness designation is the formal process of identifying the experts who will testify in a case and disclosing their qualifications, opinions, and reports to the other parties. This step ensures that all sides know in advance who will be providing specialized testimony.

    • Identifies experts for trial.

    • Discloses qualifications and opinions.

    • Part of case preparation process.

    • Required by court rules.

    Why is expert witness designation important?

    Expert witnesses can provide critical testimony about medical care, accident reconstruction, economics, and more. Proper designation helps avoid surprise witnesses and ensures fair trial preparation.

    • Ensures fair notice to all parties.

    • Allows cross-examination preparation.

    • Strengthens credibility of testimony.

    • Complies with discovery rules.

    When must experts be designated?

    Courts set deadlines for designating expert witnesses, often months before trial. Missing the deadline can mean losing the ability to use that expert at trial.

    • Deadlines set by court scheduling orders.

    • Often months before trial.

    • Late designation may be barred.

    • Strict compliance required.

    What information must be disclosed?

    Typically, parties must disclose the expert’s name, contact information, qualifications, and a summary of their opinions. In federal court and many states, a detailed written report is also required.

    • Name and contact info.

    • Qualifications and experience.

    • Summary of opinions.

    • Written report if required.

    Conclusion:
     Expert witness designation is a key procedural step that ensures transparency and fairness in personal injury litigation. Missing deadlines can be a costly mistake.

    What is expert witness designation?

    It’s the process of formally identifying and disclosing the experts who will testify in a case.

    To give all parties a fair chance to prepare for expert testimony.

    You may lose the right to use that expert at trial.

    Medical specialists, accident reconstructionists, economists, and vocational experts.

    Additional Articles

    Explore All Articles
    [eac_elementor_tmpl id="1476"]
    Posted on

    What is Prejudgment Interest?

    What is Prejudgment Interest?

    What is prejudgment interest in personal injury law?

    Prejudgment interest is the interest that accrues on a damage award from the date the injury occurred (or the claim arose) until the date of judgment. Its purpose is to compensate the injured party for the lost use of their money during the time between the injury and the court’s final decision.

    • Interest on damages from injury date to judgment.

       

    • Compensates for lost use of money.

       

    • Encourages timely settlement.

       

    • Helps make victims financially whole.

       

    Why is prejudgment interest important?

    Without it, a defendant could delay proceedings without financial penalty, effectively benefitting from holding onto money they owe. Prejudgment interest levels the playing field by ensuring victims are compensated for the delay.

    • Discourages stall tactics.

       

    • Rewards timely resolution.

       

    • Ensures fuller compensation.

       

    • Reflects time value of money.

       

    How is prejudgment interest calculated?

    The calculation depends on state law and can be based on a statutory interest rate or the prime rate. Some states calculate it from the date of the injury; others use the date the lawsuit was filed.

    • Rate set by state statute or court rule.

       

    • May start from injury date or filing date.

       

    • Simple or compound interest may apply.

       

    • Rules vary by jurisdiction.

       

    Do all states allow prejudgment interest?

    No. Some states allow it in personal injury cases, while others limit it to contract disputes or prohibit it altogether. Where allowed, the rules can differ significantly.

    • Availability depends on state law.

       

    • May apply only to certain case types.

       

    • Some states prohibit it for personal injury.

       

    • Check local statutes.

       

    Conclusion:
     Prejudgment interest can significantly increase a damage award and helps ensure injury victims are fairly compensated for the time they’ve waited for justice.

    What is prejudgment interest?

    It’s interest on a damage award from the time of the injury until the court issues judgment.

    No — rules vary widely.

    To fairly compensate victims for the delay in receiving damages.

    No — it’s set by state law and may vary.

    Additional Articles

    Explore All Articles
    [eac_elementor_tmpl id="1476"]
    Posted on

    What is Civil Conspiracy?

    What is Civil Conspiracy?

    What is civil conspiracy in personal injury law?

    Civil conspiracy occurs when two or more people agree to commit an unlawful act — or a lawful act by unlawful means — that results in harm to someone. In personal injury cases, it often involves coordinated actions to conceal negligence, defraud a victim, or obstruct justice.

    • Agreement between two or more people.

       

    • Goal is unlawful conduct or unlawful means.

       

    • Must cause harm to a victim.

       

    • Can arise in varied personal injury contexts.

       

    What elements must be proven for civil conspiracy?

    While specifics vary by state, plaintiffs generally must show:
     (1) an agreement between the defendants,
     (2) an intent to commit an unlawful act,
     (3) an act in furtherance of the conspiracy, and
     (4) resulting damages.

    • Agreement between parties.

       

    • Intent to commit wrongful act.

       

    • Action taken to advance conspiracy.

       

    • Harm to the plaintiff.

       

    How does civil conspiracy relate to personal injury claims?

    It may appear when parties coordinate to hide evidence, lie about accident details, or engage in fraudulent billing for medical services. The conspiracy itself becomes an additional cause of action alongside the underlying claim.

    • Can involve cover-ups of negligence.

       

    • May include false statements about an accident.

       

    • Can relate to insurance fraud.

       

    • Adds another legal claim for damages.

       

    What are the consequences of civil conspiracy?

    Defendants found liable for civil conspiracy can be held jointly and severally responsible for all damages caused by the conspiracy. This means each conspirator may be required to pay the full amount.

    Conclusion:
     Civil conspiracy can turn an ordinary injury case into a complex legal battle by adding a claim based on coordinated wrongful conduct.

    What is civil conspiracy?

    It’s when two or more people agree to commit an unlawful act or achieve a lawful act by unlawful means, causing harm.

    It can be — but here it refers to a civil claim for damages.

    By showing an agreement, wrongful intent, an act in furtherance, and resulting harm.

    Any party who participated in and furthered the conspiracy.

    Additional Articles

    Explore All Articles
    [eac_elementor_tmpl id="1476"]